9.
Licensing
Licensing is a
sub-category of regulation and so all of the same basic points regarding
regulation apply to licensing.
Licensing is sold to the public on the basis that it protects consumers
from low quality. What licensing
in fact does is protect the licensed from lower prices for their services! Licensing is a means by which a special
interest group--those licensed--restrict the supply of a service in order to
generate higher prices for themselves.
Licensing overrides
the preferences of consumers by setting the government as the decision maker in
quality standards for various services.
In effect, a particular level of quality is established by law thereby
forbidding any lower quality services and depriving the consumer of his
sovereignty. Many would claim that
it is necessary to have such quality standards, but often the quality standards
actually have very little to do with the service being rendered. The requirement of passing a
"History of Barbering" course in order to get a license to barber is
one such example.
But further,
consumers often prefer and need--due to income limitations--cheaper, lower
quality services. High licensing
standards often require the equivalent of a Cadillac when many are better
served by a Volkswagen. Also, the
resulting higher prices which consumers face result in more do-it-yourself
efforts and deferred work, often endangering the consumer more than licensing
protects him. Besides, there are
alternatives to coercive licensing.
Quality standards voluntarily certified allow the consumer to shop for
his preferred level of service (Underwriters Laboratories, Good Housekeeping
seals, and insurance requirements are examples). Government licensing has preempted a vast array of
certifications which would otherwise exist. These certifications would be driven by consumer demand
rather than political pull--undeniably a more satisfactory arrangement for the
consumer.
-
Burris, Alan
A Liberty Primer,
(Rochester, New York: Society for Individual Liberty, 1983) pp. 227 - 228.
-
Friedman, Milton
Capitalism and Freedom,
(Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1975) pp. 137 - 161.
-
Novak, Michael
The Spirit of Democratic Capitalism,
(New York: Simon and Schuster, 1982)
-
Rottenberg, Simon
Occupational Licensure and Regulation,
(Washington, D. C.: American Enterprise Institute, 1980)
-
Williams, Walter
The State Against Blacks,
(New York: McGraw-Hill, 1982) pp. 67 - 107.
-
Young, David
The Rule of Experts,
(Washington, D. C.: The Cato Institute, 1987)
|